Page 1 of 2

Audio Track in Song Arranger for G-Stomper Producer

Posted: Sun Jul 19, 2020 8:59 am
by Rasel Miah
Is it possible to get G-Stomper Producer with real time audio track recording or track pattern based audio loops import feature for Song Arranger in future??
I am asking because I think without this feature G-Stomper Producer is incomplete....Thanks for the amazing app...

Re: Audio Track in Song Arranger for G-Stomper Producer

Posted: Sun Jul 19, 2020 12:15 pm
by planet-h
Thanks for your feedback. Audio tracks are not planned for the near future, sorry.

Re: Audio Track in Song Arranger for G-Stomper Producer

Posted: Sun Jul 19, 2020 1:23 pm
by Rasel Miah
Is it technically possible to add this feature to G-Stomper Producer or not?
Thanks for the reply...

Re: Audio Track in Song Arranger for G-Stomper Producer

Posted: Sun Jul 19, 2020 1:52 pm
by planet-h
Rasel Miah wrote:Is it technically possible to add this feature to G-Stomper Producer or not?
Thanks for the reply...

Audio Tracks (for loops or for longer audio streams) do not (yet) exist in GSP and are not planned for the near future, sorry.

Re: Audio Track in Song Arranger for G-Stomper Producer

Posted: Tue Aug 25, 2020 6:32 pm
by ReadingSteiner_11
Okay, good to know. It'd have been a nice addition to have, but I'm already satisfied with the current state of Producer, so not having it isn't an actual issue.

Re: Audio Track in Song Arranger for G-Stomper Producer

Posted: Wed Aug 26, 2020 3:03 am
by Rasel Miah
Me too...But you know Producer is about music production app so it is also necessary to make it complete DAW...Of course, what features it has are the best on android. ...

Re: Audio Track in Song Arranger for G-Stomper Producer

Posted: Wed Aug 26, 2020 6:42 am
by planet-h
ReadingSteiner_11 wrote:Okay, good to know. It'd have been a nice addition to have, but I'm already satisfied with the current state of Producer, so not having it isn't an actual issue.

Rasel Miah wrote:Me too...But you know Producer is about music production app so it is also necessary to make it complete DAW...Of course, what features it has are the best on android. ...

Thanks a lot for the kind words, guys :).
Unfortunately, audio tracks simply do not work very well on Android, especially when you're up to record for example vocals in real-time (and I think that's what most users want to do with audio tracks). It has been already proven by other apps, that it simply doesn't work as I'd expect it from a final product. The main reason for it are the many different Android Hardware variations in the wild. Audio Output Latency goes from less than 10ms up to 300ms, depending on manufacturer and Android version.
Maybe in another time, when Google starts to force manufacturers to build devices by a specific set of rules, and to use stock Android instead of letting them change the system. If there would have been a way to do it in a way that I believe it it is "professional" enough for a final product, then I would have done it for sure.

Re: Audio Track in Song Arranger for G-Stomper Producer

Posted: Thu Aug 27, 2020 2:06 pm
by ReadingSteiner_11
You're welcome, thank you and the team for giving us such an awesome tool.
It's interesting to learn why exactly this feature won't be added, it makes sense (and it proves the user base you're actually listening to them)

Re: Audio Track in Song Arranger for G-Stomper Producer

Posted: Tue Jan 10, 2023 7:35 am
by byter
Hi,

Good to know, I guess. Although having it would have been wonderful, I'm quite happy with Producer as it is, so its absence isn't a real problem. I also work on furniture.

Re: Audio Track in Song Arranger for G-Stomper Producer

Posted: Wed Jan 11, 2023 1:25 pm
by planet-h
Welcome to the forum, byter.

byter wrote:Good to know, I guess. Although having it would have been wonderful, I'm quite happy with Producer as it is, so its absence isn't a real problem. I also work on furniture.

Thanks a lot for your feedback. That's much appreciated.